Article Text

  1. M. Allian-Sauer1,
  2. W. H. Capell1,
  3. J. P. Sutherland1,
  4. P. Wolfe1,
  5. N. D. Talley1,
  6. T. L. Hernandez1,
  7. H. R. Wyatt1,
  8. S. Klein1,
  9. G. Foster2,
  10. J. O. Hill1,
  11. R. H. Eckel1
  1. 1University of Colorado at Denver Health Sciences Center, Denver, CO; Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, MO
  2. 2Temple University School of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA.


Introduction Diets with altered macronutrient composition have become a popular method of weight loss. Because a frequent claim made about low-carbohydrate diets relates to the beneficial effects on lipid and lipoprotein metabolism, ie lower triglycerides and higher HDL cholesterol, we sought to assess the impact of low-calorie/low-fat vs low-carbohydrate diets on fasting and 24-hour excursions of triglycerides (TGs) and free fatty acids (FFAs).

Methods Thirty-five subjects were randomized to either a low-calorie/low-fat (LCAL; calorie restricted, < 30% fat, 15% protein and > 55% carbohydrate) or low-carbohydrate (LCARB; < 20 g carbohydrate/day, no limitations on fat or protein intake) diet. Subjects underwent two 24-hour feeding studies on the GCRC at baseline and 6 weeks following randomization. During each feeding study, subjects consumed three standardized meals during which TGs, FFAs, insulin, and glucose were measured hourly. During baseline studies, test meals contained 50% carbohydrates, 35% fat, and 15% protein for all subjects. During the 6- week studies, test meal composition reflected each subject's randomized diet.

Results The average weight loss at 6 weeks was not significantly different by diet (−12.92 ± 7.3 and −14.47 ± 10.6 pounds) for the LCAL and LCARB groups, respectively. Twenty-four-hour TG excursions also did not differ between both groups at 6 weeks. In contrast, 24-hour FFAs were nearly twofold higher in the LCARB group (AUC, 9,864.3 ± 1711.9 vs 5,199.6 ± 1,119.1, p < .0001), associated with persistently low insulin and glucose levels on the low-carbohydrate diet. When comparing baseline with 6 weeks within diet groups, fasting and 24-hour TG were significantly lowered in both the LCAL and LCARB groups, despite the dramatic differences in 24-hour FFA.

Conclusion Our data suggest that the effects of weight loss predominate over dietary macronutrient composition in the overall reduction of TGs. Conversely, the persistently elevated 24-hour FFA levels on the low-carbohydrate diet are likely a direct effect of differing dietary macronutrient compositions. The clinical implications of these divergent effects on lipids have not yet been defined.

Statistics from

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.